0 items in Cart
Carmela's Pizzeria Logo
  • Home
  • Menu
  • Gallery
  • Contact Us
  • Catering
  • Careers
  • Order Online
  • 0 items in Cart
  • Home
  • Menu
  • Gallery
  • Contact Us
  • Catering
  • Careers
  • Order Online
Group Order Sign Up For Deals

Carmela's Pizzeria Online Ordering Menu

2015 SOUTH DAYTON LAKEVIEW
NEW CARLISLE, OH 45344
(937) 849-1112
Noon - Midnight
90% of 97 customers recommended
Start your carryout or delivery order.
Check Availability

APPETIZERS

Deep-Fried Mushrooms 
$8.99+
Breadsticks (4) 
4 Breadsticks served with marinara & garlic butter.
$4.49
Chicken Tenders 
Hand breaded chicken tenders served with dipping sauce.
$8.99+
Deep-Fried Pickles 
Deep fried pickle spears
$8.99+
Jalapeno Cream Cheese Poppers 
$8.99+
Pretzel Sticks with Cheese 
6 pretzel sticks served with cheese.
$5.99
Potato Skins 
Stuffed with bacon and cheddar
$8.99+
Mac & Cheese Bites 
$8.99+
Mozzarella Cheese Sticks 
$8.99+
Onion Rings 
$6.99
Quesadillas 
Cheese, chicken, or beef quesadilla with mozzarella cheese, cheddar cheese, and our marinated tomatoes.
$8.99+
Texas Cheese Fry 
Seasoned french fries topped with jalapeno cheddar nacho cheese, bacon and onions.
$8.99+
Wings (Boneless) 
Hot, Mild, BBQ, Garlic, Sweet Chili, or Roasted Garlic Parm.
$8.99+
Wings (Traditional) 
Breaded bone in wings topped with either Hot, Mild, BBQ, Garlic, Sweet Chili, or Roasted Garlic Parm. Naked option available upon request.
$8.99+
Sampler Platter 
A mix of mozzarella cheese sticks, jalapeno poppers, potato skins, fried pickles, chicken tenders & deep-fried mushrooms. Served with ranch, honey mustard, marinara, and sour cream.
$13.99
Cheddar Cheese Sauce 
$1.50
FRIED SHRIMP 
$7.00
BAKED MEATBALLS 
$4.99
PARM CRUSTED FRIES 
$6.00

SALADS

Antipasta Salad 
Mixed greens lettuce, pepperoni, ham, bacon, mixed peppers, onions, black & green olives, & banana peppers covered with mozzarella.
$9.99+
Caesar Salad 
$8.99+
Chicken Caesar Salad 
Crisp romaine mixed with grated romano, shaved parmesan cheese and garlic croutons. Topped with warm chicken breast & served with Caesar dressing.
$9.99+
Buffalo Chicken Salad 
Fresh greens mixed with tomatoes, red onion, bacon, cheddar cheese and topped with grilled chicken mixed in a thick hot sauce. Served with ranch dressing.
$9.99+
Chef Salad 
Crisp mixed greens topped with ham, turkey, bacon, sliced egg, tomatoes & cheese.
$9.99+
Grilled Chicken Salad 
Crisp mix greens, sliced red onion, bacon & diced tomato. Topped with cheddar cheese & grilled chicken.
$9.99+
Fried Chicken Salad 
Crisp mix greens, sliced red onion, bacon & diced tomato. Topped with cheddar cheese & fried chicken.
$9.99+
Mediterranean Salad 
Mixed greens, dried cranberries, mandarin oranges. Topped with strawberries, blueberries, walnuts & feta cheese. Served with raspberry vinaigrette.
$9.99+
Side Salad 
Mixed greens topped with our signature marinated tomato basil & onion mixture, cheddar cheese, croutons and choice of dressing.
$2.99+
Walnut Chicken Salad (Large) 
Our Mediterranean salad with shredded chicken breast.
$11.99+
Carmela's Garden Salad (Large) 
Mixed greens, marinated tomato basil & red onion, cheddar cheese & croutons.
$8.99+

ENTREES - PASTA

All pasta served with a warm bread stick.
Kick'n Chicken Tenders (2) with (1) Side 
$6.99+
Kick'n Chicken Tenders (2) with (2) Sides 
$7.99+
Kick'n Chicken Tenders (3) with (1) Side 
$8.99+
Kick'n Chicken Tenders (3) with (2) Sides 
$9.99+
Baked Penne 
Penne pasta coated with ricotta cheese & pasta sauce. Topped with melted mozzarella.
$9.99
Chicken Parmesan Dinner 
Fried chicken topped with cheese & pasta sauce over spaghetti
$9.99
Spaghetti 
$7.99
Spaghetti with Meatballs 
$8.99
Marinated Meatball 
$1.00
Add Meatball 
$1.00
Extra Meat 
$2.00
Combo 2. Kick'n Chicken 
2 pieces of hand breaded chicken tenders, choice of side and a piece of toast.
$8.99+
Combo 4. Baked Penne 
Penne pasta coated with ricotta cheese & pasta sauce. Topped with melted mozzarella.
$9.99+
Add Chicken 
$2.00
Fish & Chips (1) 
Fried pollock with fries and Cole slaw
$9.99+
Fish & Chips (2) 
Fried pollock with fries and Cole slaw
$11.99+

PIZZA STANDARD

Our hand-stretched pizza is made from scratch daily using only the best ingredients.
Cheese Pizza (7") 
$4.49+
Topped Pizza (7") 
$4.49+
Cheese Pizza (10") 
$9.99+
Topped Pizza (10") 
$9.99+
Cheese Pizza (14") 
$13.99+
Topped Pizza (14") 
$13.99+
Cheese Pizza (18") 
$18.99+
Topped Pizza (18") 
$18.99+
Combo 1. Pizza 
$8.99+

SPECIALTY PIZZA

Our hand-stretched pizza is made from scratch daily using only the best ingredients.
Deluxe Pizza (7') 
Pepperoni, sausage, ham, mixed peppers, green olives, black olives, onions, banana pepper & mushrooms.
$7.99+
Buffalo Chicken (10") 
Hot sauce, diced chicken breast, peppers & onions, topped with cool ranch dressing.
$12.99+
Chicken Bacon Ranch (10") 
Ranch dressing, mixed peppers, diced onions, bacon & diced chicken breast.
$12.99+
Deluxe Pizza (10") 
Pepperoni, sausage, ham, mixed peppers, green olives, black olives, onions, banana pepper & mushrooms.
$12.99+
Hawaiian (10") 
Diced ham, pineapple chunks & double cheese.
$12.99+
Meat Lovers (10") 
Pepperoni, ham, sausage, & bacon with extra cheese.
$12.99+
Park Layne Special (10") 
Pepperoni, mushrooms, mixed peppers, onions, black & green olives, bacon & topped with extra cheese.
$12.99+
Veggie Delight (10") 
Mixed peppers, onions, marinated tomatoes, green & black olives, banana peppers & mushrooms.
$12.99+
Buffalo Chicken (14") 
Hot sauce, diced chicken breast, peppers & onions, topped with cool ranch dressing.
$19.99+
Chicken Bacon Ranch (14") 
Ranch dressing, mixed peppers, diced onions, bacon & diced chicken breast.
$19.99+
Deluxe Pizza (14") 
Pepperoni, sausage, ham, mixed peppers, green olives, black olives, onions, banana pepper & mushrooms.
$19.99+
Hawaiian (14") 
Diced ham, pineapple chunks & double cheese.
$19.99+
Meat Lovers (14") 
Pepperoni, ham, sausage, & bacon with extra cheese.
$19.99+
Park Layne Special (14") 
Pepperoni, mushrooms, mixed peppers, onions, black & green olives, bacon & topped with extra cheese.
$19.99+
Veggie Delight (14") 
Mixed peppers, onions, marinated tomatoes, green & black olives, banana peppers & mushrooms.
$19.99+
Buffalo Chicken (18") 
Hot sauce, diced chicken breast, peppers & onions, topped with cool ranch dressing.
$26.99+
Chicken Bacon Ranch (18") 
Ranch dressing, mixed peppers, diced onions, bacon & diced chicken breast.
$26.99+
Deluxe Pizza (18") 
Pepperoni, sausage, ham, mixed peppers, green olives, black olives, onions, banana pepper & mushrooms.
$26.99+
Hawaiian Pizza (18") 
Diced ham, pineapple chunks & double cheese.
$26.99+
Meat Lovers (18") 
Pepperoni, ham, sausage, & bacon with extra cheese.
$26.99+
Park Layne Special (18") 
Pepperoni, mushrooms, mixed peppers, onions, black & green olives, bacon & topped with extra cheese.
$26.99+
Veggie Delight (18") 
Mixed peppers, onions, marinated tomatoes, green & black olives, banana peppers & mushrooms.
$26.99+

COMBO MEALS

Combo 1. Pizza 
$8.99+
Combo 2. Kick'n Chicken 
2 pieces of hand breaded chicken tenders, choice of side and a piece of toast.
$8.99+
Combo 3. Burger 
$9.99+
Combo 4. Baked Penne 
Penne pasta coated with ricotta cheese & pasta sauce. Topped with melted mozzarella.
$9.99+
Combo 5. Half Sub 
$9.99+

SANDWICHES

Quarter pound burgers served with lettuce, sliced pickles, red onion and sliced tomato on a brioche roll. All burgers accompanied with French fries, onion petals, or saratoga chips. All sandwiches are served with French fries or saratoga chips.
Bacon Burger 
$8.99+
Cheese Burger 
$8.99+
Mushroom Burger 
$8.99+
Big Bob Fish Sandwich 
Served with lettuce, sliced tomato & mayo on harvest baked roll.
$10.99+
BLT 
Generous amounts of sliced bacon, lettuce & sliced tomato. Served with mayo on grilled bread.
$8.99+
Grilled Cheese Tomato & Bacon 
Melted American and provolone cheese served with sliced tomato & bacon served between grilled bread.
$9.49+
Fried Chicken Club 
Breaded chicken breast with lettuce, sliced tomato & bacon served with mayo on a brioche roll.
$8.99+
Ham & Cheese Melt 
Sliced ham, tomato & bacon with melted provolone cheese. Served with mayo on grilled bread.
$9.99+
Pork Tenderloin 
Served with lettuce, tomato, onion & pickle on a brioche bun.
$9.99+
Reuben 
Thinly sliced corned beef, sauerkraut, provolone cheese served with 1000 island dressing between grilled bread.
$10.99+
Turkey Melt 
Sliced turkey, tomato & bacon with melted provolone cheese. Served with mayo on grilled bread.
$9.99+
Combo 3. Burger 
$9.99+

SUBS

Buffalo Chicken Sub 
Buffalo sauce, diced chicken, peppers, onions with ranch dressing and provolone cheese.
$1.00+
Cheesesteak Sub 
Steak patty, pizza sauce, banana peppers & provolone cheese.
$1.00+
Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub 
Chicken, peppers, onions, bacon, ranch & provolone.
$1.00+
Ham & Cheese 
$1.00+
Italian Sub 
Salami, ham, pepperoni, banana peppers, provolone cheese. Choice of pizza sauce or Italian dressing.
$1.00+
Meatball Sub 
Pork & beef meatballs covered with sweet marinara, banana peppers & melted mozzarella.
$1.00+
Meat Lovers Sub 
Pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, banana peppers, provolone & pizza sauce.
$1.00+
Mushroom Steak Sub 
Steak patty, topped with mushrooms, provolone & mushroom gravy.
$1.00+
Phillysteak Sub 
Rib-eye steak, mayo, roasted peppers & onions, provolone & cheddar cheese.
$1.00+
Pizza Sub 
Pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, peppers, onions, black & green olives, banana peppers, pizza sauce & provolone.
$1.00+
Turkey Sub 
Turkey breast, lettuce, tomato, provolone cheese.
$1.00+
Veggie Sub 
$1.00+
Combo 5. Half Sub 
$9.99+
ROAST BEEF SUB 
$10.99+

SIDES

Side Mac N' Cheese 
$2.49
Mac & Cheese 
$4.49
French Fries 
$2.49
Coleslaw 
$2.49
Onion Chips 
$2.49
Cheddar Cheese Sauce 
$1.50
Marinated Meatball 
$1.00
Ranch 
$0.60
BBQ Sauce 
$0.60
Garlic Sauce 
$0.60
Hot Sauce 
$0.60
Extra Marinara 
$0.60
Mild Sauce 
$0.60
Sweet Chili 
$0.60
RPG 
$0.60
Salsa 
$0.60
Extra Sour Cream 
$0.60
Extra Dressing 
$0.60
Celery 
$1.00
Blue Cheese 
$0.60
Side Salad 
Mixed greens topped with our signature marinated tomato basil & onion mixture, cheddar cheese, croutons and choice of dressing.
$2.99+
Garlic Butter 
$0.60
Chipotle 
$0.60
EXTRA SAUCE/DRESSING 
$0.60

BEVERAGES

Iced Tea 
$2.49
Fountain Drink 
$2.69
2-Liter 
$3.19

DESSERTS

Brownie 
$1.29
Cheesecake 
$2.49
Chocolate Cake 
$2.49
Cookie 
$0.99
Cookielossus 
Family size chocolate chip cookie.
$6.00
FRIED CHEESECAKE 
$3.75
CHOC CARAMEL BUNDT CAKE 
$4.75
Your cart is empty.
  • Visit our Facebook Visit our Yelp
Powered by Menufy © 2022
  • Accessibility
  • Terms
  • Help
  • Privacy
Loading, please wait.